Every day, as millions of Americans go about their commutes, thousands of roadside assistance professionals work to keep our roadways clear and safe. These first responders—tow operators, highway maintenance crews, emergency roadside technicians, and more—routinely risk their lives in what has become one of America's most dangerous professions. 

A sobering study from our friends at the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety now reveals why our current safety systems are failing these essential workers, and how emerging technologies might finally tip the scales in their favor.

The comprehensive research effort, which analyzed over 1,200 scientific studies and all 50 states' regulations, paints a concerning picture of our roadside safety infrastructure. While the flashing amber lights we've all come to recognize have been the backbone of responder protection for generations, the study demonstrates they're increasingly mismatched to modern driving realities.

The Current State of Distracted Driving on the Road

Modern driving conditions are increasingly characterized by a multitude of distractions. The rise of smartphones, in-vehicle infotainment systems, and even basic activities like eating or drinking behind the wheel have contributed to a motoring public that is, by many accounts, more distracted than ever.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) categorizes distracted driving into three main types: visual distractions that take your eyes off the road, such as using a GPS or rubbernecking an accident; manual distractions that cause you to remove your hands from the wheel; and cognitive distractions that divert your mind from the task of driving.

The consequences of this widespread distraction are severe. Annually, according to NHTSA, approximately 3,000 people lose their lives in the U.S. due to car accidents involving distracted drivers, accounting for roughly 8-9% of all fatal collisions. Beyond these tragic deaths, in 2020 alone, 324,652 people were injured in car accidents caused by distracted driving. For roadside assistance professionals and other first responders, who must work in vulnerable positions along active roadways, this epidemic of distracted driving significantly heightens their daily risk of near-misses and struck-by collisions.

Limitations of Legacy Systems

The AAA researchers, led by Dr. John W. Shaw of NC State University, uncovered several critical vulnerabilities in current lighting systems:

First, the study confirms what many in the roadside assistance industry have long suspected—there's an inherent tension between visibility and glare. While brighter LED lightbars do improve detection distances, they often create disabling glare that ironically makes workers near the vehicle harder to see. This effect is particularly pronounced at night, when intense lighting can reduce visibility of nearby personnel by measurable margins.

The research also highlights surprising complexities in color selection. While amber remains the universal standard, some states have experimented with alternative color schemes—including blue or green warning lights—which showed modest improvements in certain conditions. However, researchers caution these may represent temporary novelty effects rather than lasting solutions. 

More concerningly, the study found most drivers still strongly associate red and blue lights exclusively with police and fire vehicles, potentially slowing reaction times when encountering tow trucks and other service vehicles.

Perhaps the most troubling anecdote from this study are the regulatory inconsistencies the study uncovered. With twelve states permitting red lights for tow trucks while thirty-eight prohibit them, and only a handful of states regulating flash patterns or light intensity, we've created a patchwork system where a safety configuration that's legal in one jurisdiction becomes a violation just across state lines. This creates needless complexity for national fleets and undermines efforts to establish consistent safety standards.

Beyond Flashing Lights

While the AAA study provides crucial insights into optimizing traditional lighting systems, it is becoming increasingly evident that no lighting configuration can fully compensate for the human factors affecting driver attention and perception in modern roadway environments.

This is where digital alerting systems like Safety Cloud® by HAAS Alert show particular promise. By delivering direct, unambiguous warnings to drivers through the navigation apps and vehicle infotainment systems they already use daily, these technologies create an additional layer of protection that isn't subject to the same environmental limitations as visual warnings.

The data supporting this approach is compelling. Where traditional lighting relies on drivers looking in the right direction at the right moment, digital alerts provide consistent warnings up to 30 seconds in advance, regardless of weather, light conditions, or background distractions. Drivers receive alerts directly through leading navigation apps like Waze and through compatible connected vehicle systems from manufacturers like Stellantis and Volkswagen, effectively turning every equipped vehicle into an additional set of eyes for roadside workers.

Building a Comprehensive Safety Ecosystem

The path forward as we see it is as follows:

• Optimized Lighting Configurations: Implementing the study's recommendations regarding color selection, flash patterns, and intensity levels to maximize traditional lighting effectiveness

• Regulatory Harmonization: Working toward greater consistency in state regulations to ensure safety isn't compromised at jurisdictional boundaries

• Digital Integration: Complementing physical warnings with direct-to-driver digital alerts that account for modern driving behaviors

• Industry Collaboration: Continuing partnerships between research organizations like AAA, technology providers, and responder associations to develop and implement best practices

A Shared Responsibility

Protecting roadside workers isn't just a technological challenge—it's a societal obligation. As AAA's study makes clear, achieving meaningful progress will require commitment from multiple stakeholders:

• Lawmakers must work to streamline contradictory regulations while allowing room for innovation

• Fleet operators need to evaluate both traditional and emerging safety solutions

• Drivers must recommit to basic safety practices like moving over and slowing down

• Technology providers should continue developing solutions that address real-world limitations

The measure of our success however, won't be in patents filed or regulations passed, but in lives saved and families kept whole. That's the standard we must hold ourselves to as we work to transform these findings into meaningful change.

Looking Ahead

What makes the AAA Foundation's study particularly valuable is its balanced, evidence-based approach. Rather than simply critiquing current systems, the researchers have provided a clear roadmap for improvement—one that acknowledges the value of traditional methods while embracing the potential of new technologies.

For HAAS Alert, whose mission has always centered on protecting those who protect us, these findings validate years of work while underscoring how much remains to be done. 

We wholeheartedly believe that this multi-layer vision is worth pursuing—because every roadside worker deserves to return home safely at the end of their shift.

‍

[CTA_BUTTON]